Border Wall Construction and Immigration: A View on What the U.S. Ought to Do

Ideally, it might be great to enter and leave the United States as easily as one travels from one of the 50 states to another. But, that’s not practical now. Therefore, we have border security.

Persons seeking to enter the United States from other countries often may:

·        have diseases that pose risks for United States citizens or face risks themselves from diseases  due to lack of immunizations that U.S. citizens get. Many Native American Indians died from diseases brought to America by European colonists.

·         lack English skills, putting them at risk due to inability to read warning signs, understand verbal instructions from others, or to communicate effectively, overall. English as a Second Language classes are great. And, I’d love to see more teachers of them and more students. Similarly, it would be great if more persons in the United States learned a foreign language. But, that all takes much time. What would be done in the meantime? It is expensive and time consuming to put signs in multiple languages or communicate instructions in multiple languages. It’s far better if all (or most) persons in our country share at least one common language, which is English now in the United States. 

·       pose security risks. Even if they are not terrorists, thieves, rapists, or some other type of bad criminal when they arrive, illegal immigrants who are unskilled and can’t speak English may be led to steal or commit other crimes to meet their basic needs of food, shelter, etc. Churches, synagogues, mosques, other nonprofit organizations, and the government likely would provide some aid. But, the massive needs of huge numbers of immigrants could overwhelm the aid system. Immigrants can acquire skills and learn English. But, it's easier for this to occur when the number of immigrants is limited, and a system is in place to teach them. I discuss skills and education more in the next point.     

·         lack job skills or education that would benefit the United States. Allowing a huge number (potentially millions or tens of millions?) of refugees or other immigrants into the country would be detrimental to our nation and to them if we couldn’t meet their needs. Would many join the welfare rolls? Would many end up in prisons and jails? Would many live in poverty in slums? Would they segregate themselves in areas with others sharing their culture and language, isolating themselves from mainstream life in the United States? Due to technological advances, there are fewer unskilled jobs than in the past, especially outside of the agriculture sector that attracts huge numbers of migrant workers.

For the above reasons and others, it seems wrong to allow uncontrolled immigration of a huge number of people. Therefore, we need to screen those entering the country and provide border security to prevent unauthorized access.

Improve Conditions Internationally

Over the long term, we need to improve the standard of living and overall conditions worldwide so that fewer persons seek to migrate long distances under difficult conditions. It is terrible that so many persons face such desperate conditions in their own nations that they are willing to abandon their homes and walk hundreds or thousands of miles with only what they can carry, in an effort to reach a better place to live. But, it would be far better to fix the problems in those countries than to run away from them and allow conditions there to deteriorate further.   

It would be great if all persons in all nations enjoyed abundant quality food, good housing, safe drinking water, excellent health, and freedom from war and terrorism. If national governments, religious and other nonprofit organizations, the United Nations, and international corporations work together, progress can occur toward this. But, this takes much time, as well as commitment and cooperation that is not easy to attain.

Good things are happening in some ways. International trade agreements, international aid organizations like CARE and Doctors Without Borders, the United Nations, missionaries, etc., are making progress in some ways. Still, much remains to be done. And, sadly in some ways things seem to be getting worse.

Solving these international issues is beyond the ability of the United States unilaterally or even in cooperation with other nations in the short term.

Is a Border Wall Necessary?

It’s best to avoid a border wall between countries if reasonably possible. The longest border between two countries in the world is the one between the United States and Canada. This border is relatively unguarded. Wonderful! It would be great if all international borders could be like this.

But, in the short term that is not practical. As illegal immigration soared in European countries in recent years, some of those countries took measures to secure their borders, constructing fences, walls, etc. Numerous articles have been written about this, including a June 15, 2018 Guardian article titled "What Is the current state of the migration crisis in Europe?"? written by Jon Henley.

The United States has oceans on its east and west, and a relatively unguarded northern border with Canada. The southern border of the U.S. is the focus of border security.

This southern border has a large number of illegal immigrants coming in. Though estimates of the number exist, we don't have a true count. Constructing a high, strong wall, fence, or some other type of barrier to greatly reduce the number of illegal immigrants entering the United States from Mexico seems to be the most economic short term solution to limit illegal immigration to the United States.

Even with a fence or wall, some might seek to dig under it, climb over it, tear through it, or seek to enter the United States via ship or boat along the coast. But, a fence or wall would make it more difficult to enter the country, as well as make it easier for the U.S. Border Patrol and other government agencies to monitor the border.

In addition to reducing the number of illegal immigrants, such a border barrier could reduce the inflow of illegal drugs. Huge quantities (no one knows exactly how much) of illegal drugs enter from our southern border.

Increasing the Number of Legal Immigrants

Building a border wall is just part of the solution, as is seeking to improve conditions in other countries so fewer will seek to immigrate to the United States. The United States can and should increase the number of persons allowed to legally come into the country.

Our nation’s greatness came partially from our success at assimilating a wide variety of people from various nations into a cohesive whole. Large numbers of immigrants willing and able to work hard to better themselves and to perform useful services can make our nation better. But, allowing large numbers of immigrants does not mean allowing unlimited numbers. And, these immigrants need to come in legally, not just to limit their quantity, but also so our government can do background checks, immunizations, etc., on them.  

Closing Thoughts

Solving the illegal immigration problem won’t be easy. But, part of the solution is to offer more sympathy and empathy to the immigrants and would-be immigrants while also seeking to take steps to limit the number of illegal immigrants entering.

NOTE: This article was last revised on October 27, 2018. It is partially adapted from an article the author posted on the now defunct website Craft Reports in April 2006. That website was operated by a friend of the author.

Halloween: One Christian's View on How to Treat All Hallows' Eve

As a young child I enjoyed dressing in a costume and going trick-or-treating, as well as seeing the other trick-or-treaters in their costumes. As an older child I enjoyed being at our family’s door giving out candy to the visitors and seeing their costumes.

I still enjoy certain aspects of Halloween. But I think it is better to replace traditional trick-or-treating with fun alternatives, as I discuss below.  

My current view is that going door-to-door seeking candy is not a good idea for the reasons listed below:

·         Candy typically has little nutritional value and its sugar content is harmful to teeth.

·         It seems wrong to impose on people by going door-to-door asking for treats. For example, many people either can’t afford candy, are busy with other activities, or just don’t desire to devote an hour or two to giving it out.

·         Some (much?) of the candy goes to waste as children only like certain types of it.

·         Walking the streets in darkness wearing costumes that may limit visibility and make it difficult to walk adds another risk to trick-or-treating.

·         There is also the risk of injury from dog bites, allergic reactions to candies containing certain things, dangerous objects added to candies, etc.

Brief History of Halloween

According to numerous sources, Halloween originated from an ancient Celtic festival, Samhain. Centuries later Christian denominations established All Saints’ Day on a particular day, which the Catholic Church and some other denominations changed to November 1. The day before All Saints' Day (October 31) became known as All Hallows’ Eve, which evolved into Halloween. More about the history of Halloween can be found in numerous online articles, including a piece on History.com titled “Halloween 2018,1” a LiveScience piece titled “History of Halloween,2” and a Britannica.com article titled “Halloween.3”

Trick-or-Treat?

Trick-or-treat? The concept seems unchristian and unethical by secular standards, too. Why? As noted earlier, it encourages seeking free candy and doing “tricks” to those who refuse to oblige with the junk food “treats.” Furthermore, it is dangerous for children to walk in the dark in uncomfortable costumes that may limit visibility to receive candy from strangers or casual acquaintances.

Thankfully, in actual practice the tricks are seldom done today, not even the soaping of windows that sometimes happened in my neighborhood during my childhood in the 1960s and early 1970s, nor the more dangerous deeds that sometimes happened then (turning over school bus stop shelters, placing tree limbs or other dangerous objects in roadways, etc.). Still, the name trick-or-treat does not conjure up great images if taken literally.

An Alternative to Trick-or-Treating

The alternative? Thank God for a bountiful harvest season. Celebrate autumn harvest with enjoyable games, tasty but nutritious food, and good fellowship with friends. Even for kids the best part of this autumn harvest celebration can and should be godly fellowship with friends, neighbors, and relatives. 

This fellowship can take place in homes, churches, or even community centers. Indeed, many churches, other organizations, and towns offer organized alternatives to door-to-door trick-or-treating. Traditional Halloween trick-or-treating seems unnecessary and wrong, as I see it.

Everyone enjoy a safe, fun Halloween or All Hallows’ Eve. Furthermore, on November 1, All Saints' Day, maybe it would be great to dedicate or rededicate oneself to seeking to live a righteous life. Many "saints" of the past certainly set examples that could help inspire us.    

1 “Halloween 2018;” History.com; last updated October 5, 2018, originally published November 18, 2009; webpage accessed October 21, 2018.

https://www.history.com/topics/halloween/history-of-halloween

2 “History of Halloween;” Benjamin Radford; LiveScience.com; September 18, 2017; webpage accessed October 21, 2018.

https://www.livescience.com/40596-history-of-halloween.html

3 “History of Halloween;” The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica; Britannica.com; last updated October 9, 2018; webpage accessed October 21, 2018.

https://www.britannica.com/topic/Halloween

NOTE: This article was last updated on October 23, 2018. It is partially adapted from an article I wrote that was published on the now defunct website Craft Reports in October 2006. That website was operated by a friend of mine.

Raise the Minimum Wage in the United States? Yes

Raise the minimum wage in the United States again. The majority of states already have set minimum wages higher than the federal minimum wage, as noted on a United States Department of Labor webpage.¹ And some local areas have set higher rates than either their states or the federal law.  

The federal minimum wage has been $7.25 per hour since 2009 for most jobs. The history of the minimum wage is displayed on another United States Department of Labor webpage.² Of course some persons are exempt from the minimum wage law. But the majority of workers are covered by it.

The United States flag sometimes is used to symbolize the United States government and its legal system. A higher minimum wage might make many citizens prouder of it. This photograph was taken October 23, 2016 of a flag near the courthouses in Lexington, Kentucky.

Subsidies of Low Paid Workers

Many (most?) workers who work for minimum wage or even a few dollars more than minimum age get help from relatives, friends, charities, and/or the government. Indeed, many workers who work fulltime at the minimum wage remain eligible for various federal government benefits such as food stamps (SNAP), subsidized housing, Medicaid, etc.

Such workers may get more income from various government agencies than they do from their fulltime jobs. This is often even truer for many part-time workers. Raising the minimum wage could reduce government expenditures on aid programs, while giving these workers more control over their lives by being less dependent on government assistance.

Other low wage workers are teenagers whose parents pay their basic living costs. Current laws allow employees under age 20 to be paid a minimum wage of $4.25 per hour for their first 90 days of work, $3 per hour lower than the normal minimum wage, as noted on a United States Department of Labor YouthRules webpage.³ I support keeping this $3 per hour gap for those first 90 days of work for those under age 20.

Volunteer Work and Unpaid Internships

There is a place for low-paid workers. Indeed, doing volunteer work for no pay at all for nonprofit organizations is a good way for young people to learn skills and for retirees to remain active. Unpaid internships at corporations are good for many people, too, and when such interns must be considered employees and be paid a minimum wage is discussed in a United States Department of Labor Factsheet.⁴ Indeed, devoting some time regularly to doing unpaid volunteer work, can be a blessing for most people.
    

The United States Minimum Wage and Jobs Outside the Country

I feel that employees deserve to be paid a fair living wage worldwide. Workers in several other countries may work harder, longer hours, under more unsafe conditions, and for much lower pay than workers in the United States. Such problems even contribute to some of the violence around the world. These nations need reforms, too—and international companies can help by raising wages they pay workers in those nations.

But, this article focuses on conditions in the United States. For those who feel jobs might be exported, I want to note that many jobs can’t be easily exported overseas—and a lot of those that can be already have been. Furthermore, gradually, progress is being made toward improved labor conditions worldwide via trade agreements, etc.

Does Raising the Minimum Wage Cost Jobs?

The argument can be made that raising the minimum wage costs jobs as employers lay people off or cut back on their hiring. Also, some minimum wage jobs require minimum skills and in some cases relatively little work. However, many such jobs require specific skills. And, often, even entry level, low wage jobs attract well-qualified persons, willing and able to work hard. Even if the minimum wage is increased, employers will still hire persons for jobs that need done. Often, in cases where jobs are eliminated due to technology, etc., new jobs seem to develop that offset the losses. 

Specific Recommendation

It has been over nine years since the U.S. minimum wage increased. I recommend a $1.00 per hour raise to $8.25 per hour effective either January 1, 2019 or 60 days after passage of the law increasing the minimum wage, whichever is later. I also advocate additional $1.00 per hour raises at one year intervals to raise the rate to $10.25 two years after the increase to $8.25.

These amounts and dates are open to negotiation by persons more skilled and knowledgeable than I. But a pay raise for low paid workers might stimulate the economy by increasing purchasing more than many other proposed economic stimulus measures. Do you agree that raising the United States minimum wage will be beneficial?      

Endnotes:

¹ “Minimum Wage Laws in the States”; United States Department of Labor; updated July 1, 2018. Webpage accessed October 9, 2018. https://www.dol.gov/whd/minwage/america.htm

² “History of Federal Minimum Wage Rates Under the Fair Labor Standards Act, 1938 – 2009"; United States Department of Labor. Webpage accessed October 9, 2018. https://www.dol.gov/whd/minwage/chart.htm

³ “Must young workers be paid the minimum wage?”; Frequently Asked Questions; YouthRules: Preparing the 21^st Century Workforce; United States Department of Labor. Webpage accessed October 9, 2018. https://www.youthrules.gov/know-the-limits/faq/index.htm

⁴ “Factsheet #71: Internship Programs Under the Fair Labor Standards Act”; United States Department of Labor; updated January 2018. Webpage accessed October 9, 2018. https://www.dol.gov/whd/regs/compliance/whdfs71.htm

Disclosure: My current part-time second job that keeps the bills paid while I do my freelance writing is as a store clerk at a retailer. While my hourly wage at the retail store is more than the minimum wage and God enables me to keep my budget balanced, I feel both sympathy for and
empathy with those earning at or near minimum wage. I anticipate being one of the beneficiaries if the minimum wage is increased by the amounts advocated in this article.

NOTE: This article, which was last revised on October 13, 2018 is adapted from one the author published in 2012 on another website (Newsvine) that is no longer in existence.